Menu image/svg+xml

Energy-efficient renovation: Tenants and landlords experience the same process in fundamentally different ways

Renovations to residential buildings that are energy efficient have a significant effect on the daily lives of tenants and require housing companies to take into account a wide range of economic, regulatory, and social factors. A study carried out by the Institute for Ecological Economy Research (IÖW) and the German Business Initiative for Energy Efficiency (DENEFF) shows that both tenants and landlords share an interest in the renovation process proceeding as smoothly as possible. Yet they experience the process from positions that are fundamentally unequal and often perceive the same circumstances in essentially different ways. The findings provide new understanding of the role of transparency, participation, and costs in renovation projects as well as of how such renovations influence the perception of housing quality. Smooth renovation processes depend on cooperation between tenants and landlords.

As part of the study, the researchers conducted interviews with experts as well as exchange formats and background discussions with the housing industry. They also interviewed more than 20 tenants and organized three focus groups with people who had experienced extensive energy-efficiency renovations in their apartment buildings. The study was carried out within the research project “EnSanKoop – Successful energy-efficient refurbishment through cooperation,” funded by the German Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy. It provides the foundation for developing practical solution areas and testing approaches in the next phases of the project.

Communication is critical during renovations and can also deliver economic benefits

The researchers emphasize that information and transparency are particularly important during renovation projects. Tenants see information as a sign of appreciation and as a prerequisite for planning. “Energy-efficiency renovations place a considerable burden on tenants. This is especially true for vulnerable groups,” says heating and energy expert Dr. Julika Weiß of the IÖW. “Against this backdrop, our conversations with tenants showed that emotional factors and questions of fairness play a central role.”

Landlords often view communication as a tool for securing tenants’ acceptance of the renovation measures. Communication tends to decrease after the formal modernization notice has been issued. “Housing companies often limit tenant communication during renovations to what is legally required,” says Susann Bollmann of the DENEFF. “In practice, we see that when companies deliberately go beyond these requirements, tenant acceptance and willingness to cooperate increase. This helps minimize delays and reduce the risk of conflict.”

Renovation costs: Considering economic viability and proportionality together

The renovation experience on both sides is shaped by the relationship between tenants and landlords. Tenants are in a structurally dependent position and can only assert their claims to a limited extent, such as requesting rent reductions due to disruptions caused by construction work.

Landlords and tenants also view costs and economic viability from different perspectives. For landlords, economic viability is the fundamental prerequisite for any renovation decision, particularly under challenging market conditions. Tenants, by contrast, focus on proportionality, maintaining stable total housing costs, and having a clear and understandable breakdown of renovation expenses.

After renovations, tenants often appreciate the improvements

Despite the considerable disruptions during the construction phase, tenants frequently look back on renovation projects positively. “Many tenants told us that they were pleasantly surprised by whether, and to what extent, the renovations improved their living comfort,” says Weiß. “They highlighted direct benefits of the energy-efficiency measures, such as a more comfortable indoor climate or reduced noise thanks to better-insulated windows. At the same time, non-energy-related improvements that enhance the residential environment or increase functionality are also seen by many tenants as important positive outcomes.”

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Further Information: