Energy-efficient renovations of the existing residential building stock are crucial for achieving climate goals — and at the same time, they are a process that profoundly impacts tenants’ daily lives and presents housing companies with complex economic, regulatory, and social trade-offs. Our study examines both sides: It examines what motivates and hinders landlords during renovations, and it explores what tenants need and fear. In this way, it delves into the common ground, areas of conflict, and potential solutions that emerge when both perspectives are brought together.
The study compares the perspectives of tenants and landlords across four thematic areas where their viewpoints directly intersect:
The researchers show that tenants and landlords experience the renovation process from structurally unequal positions and often with fundamentally different perspectives on the very same circumstances. Some of the conflicts arise from a lack of mutual visibility, asymmetrical perceptions, and the handling of uncertainties that neither side can solve on its own.
At the same time, there is a power imbalance between the parties involved, often to the detriment of tenants when their positions are structurally opposed — for example, on the issue of rent reductions.
The study was conducted as part of the research project “EnSanKoop – Successful energy-efficient refurbishment through cooperation” and serves as a basis for testing potential solutions as the project progresses. The findings on the landlords’ side are based on semi-structured expert interviews, dialogue formats, and supplementary background conversations with the housing industry. On the tenants’ side, 21 one-on-one interviews and three focus groups were conducted with tenants who had experienced extensive energy-efficiency renovation measures in their apartment buildings.